Simple Homemade Sandwich Recipes

Here is the Reason to Make Homemade Sandwiches Over Store-Bought Ones Every Time

One of the simplest methods of saving and healthier eating is making sandwiches at home. It is up to what you put in and you can make what you are longing to make.

Commercially prepared sandwiches usually sell at three to four times the price of home prepared ones. On top of that, they contain preservatives and the added sodium that you do not require.

You can know what you are eating when you prepare your own sandwiches. No hidden ingredients. No mystery sauces. It is just fresh and wholesome, and it is delicious.

The best part? The majority of the easy home-made sandwich recipes require less than 10 minutes to cook. It is quicker than waiting in a queue at a sandwich store.

How to Prepare Your Kitchen to Make Sandwiches Successfully

Now, we shall discuss the fundamentals you will require before you get into recipes.

Here are a Few of the Necessities That Should Be in Stock

These are the basics that you should keep in your kitchen and then you always have a sandwich ready:

  • Fresh bread (whole wheat, white, sourdough or rolls)
  • Deli meats (turkey, ham, roast beef, chicken)
  • Cheese (cheddar, Swiss, provolone, American) in slices
  • Veggies (lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions)
  • Condiments (mayo, mustard, ketchup, hot sauce)
  • Butter or margarine
  • Additions (peanut butter, jelly, hummus, cream cheese)

Making Sandwiches is a Simple Task That Can Be Made Easier with the Help of Tools

It does not necessarily require any fancy equipment:

  • Sharp knife for slicing
  • Cutting board
  • Toaster or panini press
  • Plastic bags or plastic wraps
  • Mixing bowls of a small size

Simple Quick Recipes of Sandwich

We will begin with the perennial classics that everyone loves.

The Ultimate BLT (Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato)

This sandwich of icons contains only several ingredients, and when prepared well, it is unbelievable.

What You’ll Need:

  • 2 slices of toasted bread
  • 4 strips of crispy bacon
  • 2-3 leaves of fresh lettuce
  • 2-3 slices of ripe tomato
  • 2 tablespoons of mayo
  • Salt and pepper to taste

How to Make It:

Cook your bacon till it is crispy without burning. This normally takes 8-10 minutes in a pan with medium heat.

As the bacon is cooking, toast your bread till it goes golden brown. You need it to be crispy enough to support the water content of the tomatoes.

Place mayonnaise on both pieces of toast. There will be lettuce on the first layer, followed by tomato slices. Add a touch of salt and black pepper to the tomatoes.

Place your strips of bacon over, and then cover the sandwich with the remaining slice of bread. Diagonally cut to have a traditional appearance.

The Ultimate Grilled Cheese

A well-grilled sandwich consisting of cheese is better than anything.

Ingredients:

  • 2 slices of bread
  • 2 to 3 slices of your favorite cheese
  • 2 tablespoons of butter

Steps:

Butter one side of the bread pieces. Butter must not be cold and firm as it has to be soft and spreadable.

Prepare a pan with a medium low heat. Put one slice of bread buttered side down in the pan.

Place the slices of your cheese on the top of the bread in the pan. Lay on the second piece of bread, buttered side upwards.

Bake 3-4 minutes or until the bottom is golden brown. Turn it over and continue cooking 3-4 minutes.

The key is low and slow. The bread is then burned by heat and then the cheese melts. Medium-low heat will provide you with that just right golden crust with sticky melting cheese inside.

Classic Club Sandwich

The club sandwich is a sandwich that is good three layers deep.

What You Need:

  • 3 slices of toasted bread
  • 4 slices of turkey
  • 4 slices of bacon
  • 2 slices of cheese
  • Lettuce and tomato
  • Mayo and mustard

Assembly Instructions:

Toast all three bread slices. Wipe one side of each slice with mayonnaise.

In the first slice, place layer cheese and turkey. Cover it with the second piece of bread (mayo-side down).

On the second piece, add bacon, lettuce and tomato. Close with the third slice, mayo side down.

Quartered and pinned with toothpicks. This holds it all together.

Clearly, There Are Many Creative Ways to Make a Breakfast Sandwich Idea

Energize your day with the following breakfast meals.

Egg and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich

Fast, high in protein and tasty.

Ingredients:

  • 1 English muffin or bagel
  • 1 egg
  • 1 slice of cheese
  • Salt and pepper
  • Butter or cooking spray

Method:

Toast and cut your English muffin in half. When it is toasting, prepare an egg.

In the case of a fried egg, place a small pan on the medium heat over butter. Break the egg into the pan and cook till the whites are hardened. You may crack the yolk so that it is easier to eat, or you can keep it runny.

To scramble, beat the egg in a bowl with a splash of milk and cook in a pan and stir continuously.

Put the cheese at the bottom of the half of the muffin when it is still hot. Add the egg on top. The cheese will somewhat melt under the heat. Place the lid of the muffin and savor.

Peanut Butter Banana Sandwich

Sweet, simple, surprisingly satisfying.

You’ll Need:

  • 2 slices of bread
  • 2 tablespoons peanut butter
  • 1 banana
  • Optional: honey or cinnamon

How to Build It:

Apply peanut butter on both pieces of bread. Use crunchy or smooth whatever you wish.

Cut up the banana into thin slices. Put them on a single piece of bread and peanut butter is covered.

Serve with a drizzle of honey as you please. Cinnamon is added to add a warm taste.

Place the second slice on top and push it. This is a sandwich that is nice toasted as well. All you do is butter it on the outside and grill it like a grilled cheese.

Lunch Box Champions

These are easy homemade sandwich recipes and they are easy to carry and they are very good at room temperature.

Turkey and Swiss Roll-Up

Good when you do not have a loaf of bread or feel like having something lighter.

Ingredients:

  • 1 large flour tortilla
  • 3-4 slices of turkey
  • 2 slices of Swiss cheese
  • Lettuce leaves
  • Mustard or ranch dressing

Rolling Instructions:

Place the flat of the tortilla on a clean surface. Apply a thin smear of mustard or ranch in the middle leaving approximately an inch all around the sides.

Place turkey slices in the center. Place the cheese on top of the turkey.

Cover the cheese with lettuce leaves. Ensure that all the contents remain at the center of the tortilla.

Fold the sides first then roll tightly at bottom upwards. Cut in half diagonally.

Ham and Cheese Slider

These are mini sandwiches which are easy to make in large numbers and enjoyable to eat.

What You Need:

  • Slider rolls or dinner rolls
  • Thin-sliced ham
  • Cheese slices (cut to fit)
  • Butter
  • Optional: poppy seeds, onion powder

Preparation:

Cut the rolls in half, horizontal. You may leave them attached so as to make it easier to handle.

Spread ham and cheese on the lower half. Replace the tops.

Melt butter and rub it on the surfaces of the rolls. Sprinkle over poppy seeds, preferably.

These could be eaten in their cold form or put in the oven at 350°F to warm up and melt the cheese in 10 minutes.

Hot Sandwich Recipes That Hit the Spot

When you are in the mood of something warm and cozy, then you should try these.

Tuna Melt Supreme

In this pleasing mixture, tuna salad is coupled with grilled cheese.

Ingredients:

  • 1 can of tuna, drained
  • 2 tablespoons mayo
  • 1 tablespoon diced celery
  • 2 slices of bread
  • 2 slices of cheese
  • Butter for grilling

Making the Tuna Salad:

Add tuna, mayo and celery in a bowl. Add a pinch of salt and pepper.

Butter one side of the slices of bread. Add one slice of butter with the butter side into a pan on the medium heat.

Spoon the tuna in the pan on bread. Add cheese slices on top. Close it with the second slice, butter-side up.

Bake to turn golden brown on each side, approximately 4 minutes per side.

Philly Cheesesteak Style Sandwich

Get the Philadelphian flavor on the comfort of the house using this hearty recipe.

You’ll Need:

  • 1 hoagie roll
  • 6 ounces of thinly sliced beef
  • 1/2 sliced onion
  • 1/2 sliced green pepper
  • 2 slices provolone cheese
  • 1 tablespoon oil

Cooking Steps:

Heat in a pan, over medium-high heat, heat oil. Add onions and peppers. Cook until tender, approximately 5 minutes.

Push vegetables to the side. Add the beef to the pan. Breaking it with a spatula, cook until browned.

Combine the vegetables and the beef. Lay cheese slices on it and allow melting.

Split your hoagie roll in half and scoop everything inside. The roll must be soft to be able to absorb the juices but hard enough to support everything.

Vegetarian Simple Homemade Sandwich Recipes

Meatless doesn’t mean boring. These alternatives are full of flavor.

Caprese Sandwich

Tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and basil make an Italian masterpiece.

Ingredients:

  • Fresh mozzarella slices
  • Ripe tomato slices
  • Fresh basil leaves
  • Balsamic vinegar
  • Olive oil
  • Ciabatta bread or baguette
  • Salt and pepper

Assembly:

Cut your bread and sprinkle the inside with olive oil. You may lightly toast it.

Add slices of mozzarella, followed by tomato slices. Lay basil leaves in between the layers.

Garnish with balsamic vinegar. Add salt and pepper.

This sandwich serves best when the sandwich materials are not cold out of the refrigerator.

Hummus Veggie Wrap

Fresh, vibrant and crunchy.

What You Need:

  • 1 large tortilla or flatbread
  • 3 tablespoons hummus
  • Sliced cucumbers
  • Shredded carrots
  • Lettuce or spinach
  • Sliced bell peppers

Building Your Wrap:

Spread hummus all the way to the tortilla. This serves as taste as well as paste.

Prepare a row of all the vegetables. Not to be too full or it will not roll.

Turn the sides in, and roll up tight along the bottom. Press firmly as you roll.

Slice in half on an angle. This wrap is made to look just as good as it tastes because of the coloring of vegetables.

How to Make Sandwiches That Actually Stay Together

There is nothing that is worse than a sandwich that collapses after you take it.

The Right Order Matters

Pour wet ingredients into the center. Lettuce and cheese are placed against the bread to form moisture barrier.

Add condiments to each of the two slices. This assists in holding it all together.

Don’t overload. More isn’t always better. Extravagant ingredients make an ugly sandwich.

Bread Selection Makes a Difference

Light cold sandwiches with light fillings would be done with soft bread. Heavy, wet ingredients support hearty bread.

Toast bread to make it more stable. The bread is soft and the surface is crispy and repels moisture better.

New bread is better, whereas day-old bread is really effective in grilled sandwiches. It doesn’t get soggy as easily.

Simple Homemade Sandwich Recipes Comparison Table

Sandwich TypePrep TimeDifficultyBest For
BLT10 minutesEasyLunch
Grilled Cheese8 minutesEasyAny meal
Club Sandwich15 minutesMediumLunch/Dinner
Egg & Cheese7 minutesEasyBreakfast
PB & Banana5 minutesVery EasyBreakfast/Snack
Tuna Melt12 minutesMediumLunch
Hummus Veggie8 minutesEasyLunch
Caprese6 minutesEasyLunch

Sandwich Shopping Guide That is Budget-Friendly

Preparing sandwiches at home costs you a lot less, and smart shopping costs even less.

Cost Breakdown Per Sandwich

An average homemade sandwich costs a range of between $1.50-$3.00 to make. That is compared to $6-10 in a restaurant or deli.

Purchase deli meat in large quantities and freeze half. It has a freezing life of up to 2 months.

Name brands are not better than generic brand bread, cheese, and condiments. You can cut costs by 30% or more.

Meal Prep Ideas

Prepare sandwich fillings in advance. Tuna salad, egg salad, and chicken salad are preserved in 3-4 days in refrigerator.

Wash vegetables in advance on Sunday. Keep them in boxes where they can be assembled on a weekly basis.

Keep the bread in a freezer in case you are not using it quickly. Fry frozen toast right out of the freezer.

Bringing Your Sandwiches to the Next Level

When you have got the basics, attempt the following upgrades. For more creative food ideas and recipes, explore different flavor combinations.

Homemade Spreads and Sauces

Combine sriracha and mayo to create spicy mayo. To make garlic bread spreads, add herbs and garlic powder to butter.

Mash avocado with lime juice and salt for fresh guacamole. This is brilliant in place of mayo.

Mayo and mustard in equal parts mixed with a small portion of pickle juice making a special sauce.

Creative Add-Ins Nobody Thinks About

Potato chips in your sandwich give it crunch. Seriously, try it.

Pickles do not only go with hamburgers. They are giving flavor to nearly any sandwich.

A jam on a sandwich of turkey is strange but really delicious. The savory and sweet mixture succeeds.

Preparing Sandwiches That Remain Fresh

Having a sandwich that you have to carry? Here’s how to keep it perfect.

Wrapping Techniques

Place in plastic wrap or parchment paper. This helps to avoid air drying up the bread.

In the case of hot sandwiches, place in aluminum foil. This will make them warm and avoid sogginess.

To make the sandwich more than 2 hours before eating it, pack wet ingredients separately. Add them right before eating.

Storage Tips

Store sandwiches in fridge in cases where one will not consume the food in less than 2 hours. Food safety matters.

Do not leave mayo filled sandwiches at room temperature above 2 hours. Bacteria grow fast.

Use an ice pack in lunch boxes. This enables it to keep everything in a safe temperature till lunch time.

Frequently Asked Questions About Simple Homemade Sandwich Recipes

What is the maximum period of time when I can store a homemade sandwich in the fridge?

Sandwiches can be kept at 24 hours in the refrigerator. Mayo or other creamy spreads should be consumed as sandwiches within this period. Dry sandwich such as the PB & J has a shelf life of 2-3 days.

What is the best bread used in sandwiches?

It depends on your sandwich. Most cold sandwiches are served on soft white or wheat bread. Hot sandwiches are better supported by sourdough or ciabatta. Whole grain bread is also nutritious and fibrous.

Is it possible to freeze sandwiches?

Yes, but not every sandwich conditions itself to be frozen. Jelly and peanut butter freeze well. It works also with meat and cheese without wet vegetables. Don’t freeze sandwiches with lettuce, tomatoes, or mayo. They get soggy when thawed.

What can I do to add more to my sandwich?

Include extra meat, cheese, eggs or nut butter. Add healthy fats such as avocado. Eat whole grain bread to get more fiber. These additions will leave you content longer.

What is the alternative to bread?

As a low-carb food, try lettuce wraps. Use tortillas for wraps. English muffins and bagels are also good. You may even make huge portobello mushroom caps your buns.

Why does my sandwich get soggy?

Wet ingredients are moist and the moisture penetrates into the bread. Place lettuce or cheese on the bread to form a barrier. Toast the bread to offer additional coverage. Add wet ingredients such as tomatoes just before eating.

Are homemade sandwiches healthier as compared to those available in stores?

Usually yes. You decide what is in you and how much. You can omit the preservatives and save sodium. The homemade sandwiches are usually made with less processed food and more vegetables.

What is the beginner friendly sandwich?

Begin with peanut butter and jelly. You can’t really mess it up. When you are relaxed, have a plain ham and cheese. Then proceed to grilled cheese and more complicated dishes.

Preparing Sandwiches with Kids as Play

Children can learn a lot by being taken into the kitchen.

Kid-Friendly Recipes

Allow children to make their own sandwiches. Prepare foods buffet-style and leave them to make a choice.

Make fun shapes with cookie cutters. Lunch is exciting with stars, hearts and animals.

Have a sandwich bar during a birthday or a playdate. Children prefer to personalize their food.

Teaching Moments

Sandwiches provide simple cooking knowledge. Children learn to spread, layer and combine.

They train on how to follow instructions when using recipes. This develops comprehension and reading.

Children feel confident when they prepare their own food. They take pride in consuming a thing they came up with.

The Reason Simple Homemade Sandwich Recipes Will Never Become Obsolete

Sandwiches are not a new concept, and they are popular because of a reason. According to America’s Test Kitchen, mastering basic sandwich techniques opens up endless culinary possibilities.

They’re versatile. You may have them in the breakfast, lunch, dinner, and snacks.

They’re portable. Carry them anywhere without any special storage facilities or tools.

They’re customizable. Every person can create what they desire.

Most importantly they unite people. Eating a sandwich with a person makes connection.

Your Dream of Making a Sandwich Begins Here

It is now time to have all ingredients to create amazing simple homemade sandwich recipes.

Begin with the simple recipes in this guide. Learn the classics such as grilled cheese and BLT.

Then experiment yourself and make your own combinations. The finest sandwich is the one that you prepare yourself.

It does not necessarily need to be complex in cooking. The most wonderful meals are the easiest.

A homemade sandwich is better than pricier food at the restaurant any day.

Get some bread, choose what fillings you like most and begin to make sandwiches that you will actually be happy to eat.

Your kitchen is ready. Ready ingredients are at hand. Time to create something good.

Leave a Comment